Continue to use the scenario to assist you with this assignment.
Healing Hands Hospital is an acute care community hospital that serves a suburban community outside of a large city with two competing large academic medical centers. Both Healing Hands Hospital and the academic medical centers have a long history of service to the region, but their business and fundamental practices are different. Your manager, Ms. Woods, Healing Hands’ Chief Operating Officer, is part of the Task Force working on the strategic plan for the hospital and needs to understand the fundamental practices of these academic medical centers.You have been asked to research the differences between the services that your organization offers and those of at least one of these academic medical centers. For the purposes of this assignment, use the Web to research community hospitals and academic medical centers and select one community hospital and one academic medical center located in the same city or area to represent these two healthcare organizations for the purpose of working on this assignment. You will use the information that you find about these two healthcare organizations for the Individual Project assignments in the remaining weeks of the course culminating in your final project in Week 5. Use the acute-care community hospital to represent Healing Hands Hospital. This link provides a list of example community hospitals. Choose one and then find an academic medical center located in the same geographic region. Review the Web information on these facilities to complete this assignment.1. Describe the similarities and differences of these organizations in terms of the following:
- Management structure
- Reimbursement models
- Research and clinical trials
2. Based on your analysis of the data that you present, provide your opinion on what would be the main areas of concern if the two organizations were to merge and how they could be overcome.
You may include a table for the comparison data, but you must describe your evaluation of where there are and are not similarities between the two healthcare organizations and your opinion. Be sure to document your references using APA format. This includes the websites for the two hospitals that you are using for the assignment.Reference: 100 Great community Hospitals (2016). Becker’s Hospital Review. Retrieved from
Please submit your assignment.
For assistance with your assignment, please use your text, Web resources, and all course materials.
Expert Solution Preview
In this assignment, we will be comparing an acute-care community hospital, Healing Hands Hospital, with an academic medical center located in the same geographic region. We will analyze the similarities and differences between these two healthcare organizations in terms of their mission, goals, objectives, management structure, reimbursement models, staffing, policies, procedures, and research and clinical trials. Additionally, based on this analysis, we will identify potential areas of concern if the two organizations were to merge and propose ways to overcome these concerns.
Healing Hands Hospital: The mission of Healing Hands Hospital is to provide high-quality, compassionate healthcare services to the suburban community it serves, ensuring the well-being and satisfaction of patients.
Academic Medical Center: The mission of the academic medical center is twofold – to provide excellent patient care while also advancing medical knowledge through research and education.
Similarities: Both organizations aim to provide quality healthcare services to their respective communities.
Differences: The academic medical center emphasizes research and education in addition to patient care, whereas Healing Hands Hospital focuses solely on patient care.
Healing Hands Hospital: The primary goal of Healing Hands Hospital is to meet the healthcare needs of the suburban community efficiently and effectively, while maintaining patient satisfaction and safety.
Academic Medical Center: The goals of the academic medical center include providing exceptional patient care, conducting groundbreaking research, training future healthcare professionals, and contributing to medical advancements.
Similarities: Both organizations strive to provide excellent patient care.
Differences: The academic medical center has additional goals related to research, education, and training.
Healing Hands Hospital: The objectives of Healing Hands Hospital include reducing wait times, improving patient outcomes, enhancing patient experience, and maintaining financial stability.
Academic Medical Center: The objectives of the academic medical center encompass advancing medical knowledge through research, publishing scientific findings, training medical students and residents, and providing specialized care for complex medical conditions.
Similarities: Both organizations aim to improve patient outcomes and deliver quality healthcare.
Differences: The academic medical center has additional objectives related to research, education, and specialized care.
d) Management Structure:
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital follows a hierarchical management structure with clear lines of authority and responsibility. The Chief Operating Officer oversees the hospital’s operations, and department heads report to the COO.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center also follows a hierarchical management structure, but it may have additional layers of administration due to its larger size and complex operations. In addition to department heads, there may be deans, directors, and other academic roles involved in the management structure.
Similarities: Both organizations have hierarchical management structures.
Differences: The academic medical center may have a more complex management structure due to its larger size and academic focus.
e) Reimbursement Models:
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital primarily relies on a fee-for-service reimbursement model, where payment is based on the services provided to patients.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center participates in a variety of reimbursement models, including fee-for-service, but may also have contracts with government payers, private insurers, and research grants.
Similarities: Both organizations receive payment through fee-for-service reimbursement.
Differences: The academic medical center has a more diverse reimbursement portfolio due to its involvement in research and specialized services.
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital employs a diverse range of healthcare professionals, including physicians, nurses, allied health professionals, and support staff. The staffing ratios are based on patient acuity and departmental needs.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center has a larger workforce compared to Healing Hands Hospital. It employs not only healthcare professionals but also medical researchers, educators, and administrative staff. The staffing ratios are influenced by the size and complexity of the academic medical center.
Similarities: Both organizations have healthcare professionals and support staff.
Differences: The academic medical center has a larger and more diverse workforce due to its research and educational activities.
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital has policies in place to ensure patient safety, quality of care, infection control, privacy and confidentiality, and ethical practices.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center has similar policies to Healing Hands Hospital, but it may have additional policies related to research ethics, academic integrity, and collaborations with educational institutions.
Similarities: Both organizations have policies in place to ensure patient safety and quality of care.
Differences: The academic medical center has additional policies related to research ethics and academic integrity.
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital follows standard operating procedures for various medical treatments, surgeries, and emergency protocols. These procedures are guided by evidence-based medicine and regularly updated.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center also follows standard procedures for medical treatments and surgeries. However, it may have additional procedures related to research protocols, clinical trials, and educational activities.
Similarities: Both organizations follow standard procedures for medical treatments and surgeries.
Differences: The academic medical center has additional procedures related to research and clinical trials.
i) Research and Clinical Trials:
Healing Hands Hospital: Healing Hands Hospital participates in clinical research studies and may offer patients the opportunity to participate in selected trials. However, research activities are not as extensive as in an academic medical center.
Academic Medical Center: The academic medical center is actively involved in research and clinical trials, conducting groundbreaking studies and contributing to medical advancements. It collaborates with pharmaceutical companies, research institutions, and community healthcare organizations to advance medical knowledge.
Similarities: Both organizations participate in clinical research studies and clinical trials.
Differences: The academic medical center has a more robust research program and collaborates extensively with external partners.
Based on the analysis of the data presented, the main areas of concern if Healing Hands Hospital and the academic medical center were to merge would involve managing the differences in their missions, goals, objectives, management structures, staffing, and reimbursement models.
To overcome these concerns, the following strategies could be considered:
1. Establishing a clear and unified mission: Define a mission statement that incorporates elements of both organizations’ missions, emphasizing the importance of providing high-quality patient care, advancing medical knowledge, and meeting community healthcare needs.
2. Aligning goals and objectives: Identify common goals and objectives that focus on patient care, research, education, and community outreach. Develop strategies to support these shared goals while addressing the unique needs of each organization.
3. Integrating management structures: Create an integrated management structure that ensures clear lines of authority and facilitates effective decision-making. This structure should incorporate elements of both organizations’ structures while streamlining processes to improve efficiency.
4. Developing a comprehensive staffing plan: Evaluate the workforce requirements based on the merged organization’s needs, considering both clinical and research positions. Develop a staffing plan that optimizes resources and promotes collaboration between healthcare providers, researchers, and educators.
5. Designing a flexible reimbursement model: Develop a reimbursement model that accommodates both fee-for-service payments and research funding. Consider partnering with insurance payers, government agencies, and research funding organizations to ensure financial stability and support for both patient care and research activities.
6. Harmonizing policies and procedures: Review and revise policies and procedures to ensure consistency, compliance with regulatory standards, and alignment with best practices. Incorporate elements from both organizations’ policies, adapting them as needed to reflect the merged organization’s goals and values.
7. Fostering a culture of collaboration: Encourage open communication and collaboration among healthcare professionals, researchers, educators, and administrative staff. Promote interdisciplinary approaches to patient care, research, and education, fostering an environment that values innovation and continuous improvement.
By addressing these areas of concern and implementing the suggested strategies, the merged organization can create a harmonious and successful healthcare system that combines the strengths of both Healing Hands Hospital and the academic medical center.